Speech Evaluator Script
Complete guide and script for the Toastmasters Speech Evaluator role
What is the Speech Evaluator?
The Speech Evaluator provides structured, constructive feedback on a specific prepared speech. You help the speaker understand what they did well, identify areas for growth, and leave the lectern feeling motivated to improve. Evaluations should be specific, balanced, and tied to the objectives of the speaker's project rather than personal preference.
Opening Introduction Script
"Madam/Mister General Evaluator, fellow Toastmasters, and honored guests.
I had the privilege of evaluating [Speaker's Name] today, who delivered their [project name or number] speech from the [Pathway name] pathway. The objectives for this project were [briefly state 1–2 key objectives].
My evaluation will follow the CLE format — Commend, Lessons, Elevate — to give [Speaker's Name] the most actionable feedback possible."
The CLE Evaluation Method
Commend
Start with genuine, specific praise. What did the speaker do especially well? Reference a concrete moment from their speech.
"One thing that stood out was your powerful opening story — it immediately drew everyone in and set a clear emotional tone for the speech."
Lessons
Offer 1–2 specific, actionable areas for improvement. Focus on what they can practice, not general criticism.
"One area to work on is eye contact. I noticed you referred to your notes frequently in the second half — practicing without notes could help you connect more deeply with your audience."
Elevate
End with an inspiring, forward-looking statement that motivates the speaker to continue growing.
"[Name], your passion for this topic was clear in every word. With a little more rehearsal, your next speech will be even more memorable."
What to Cover in Your Evaluation
- •Project objectives — Did the speech meet the stated objectives of the project? Address this directly.
- •Organization and structure — Was there a clear opening, body, and conclusion? Did transitions flow logically?
- •Delivery — Voice variety, pace, pauses, eye contact, gestures, and movement on stage.
- •Language and word choice — Were vivid words and imagery used? Was the message clear?
- •Impact — Did the speech achieve its intended purpose? Did it inform, persuade, or inspire?
Closing Remarks Script
"[Speaker's Name], it was a genuine pleasure to evaluate your speech today. The progress you've made is clear, and I can't wait to see where your speaking journey takes you next.
Fellow Toastmasters and guests, please join me in a round of applause for [Speaker's Name].
Madam/Mister General Evaluator, back to you."
Tips for Success
Read the project objectives beforehand
Ask the speaker which project they are delivering and review the objectives so your feedback is relevant and accurate.
Take notes during the speech
Use a notepad to jot down specific moments, quotes, and observations as the speech happens — details matter.
Be specific, not general
Vague praise ("great job!") is less helpful than specific feedback ("your use of the three-point structure made your argument very easy to follow").
Focus on 1–2 improvements only
Overloading a speaker with feedback is counterproductive. Choose the most impactful areas for growth.